RoadShoe ReviewsSite FeatureTrailUncategorized

Best Wide Foot Running Shoes of 2020 (So Far)

PSA: This is Jarrett’s wide shoe roundup and this is a safe space. As all wide foot runners know, we’ve been shunned for far too long. There are dozens of us, dammit! So this a place where my fellow wide fam can view all the good options that work for us folk who can’t squish into those “normal” width shoes.

These are all shoes that I’ve run in for the first quarter of 2020. Now, this is technically not a “Best Of” list (although my favorite shoes are indeed in here). This is a list of every wide shoe I’ve run in that’s currently available. I’ll give you the good, the bad, and everything in-between. Some shoes will have links to my full review, and others will be brief summaries of shoes I have worn but received after others on our team reviewed it (turns out very few companies care about doing pre-production runs of wide shoes).

As any runner with wide foot problems knows, the list of companies who cater to us is quite brief. You’ll also notice that the following list is New Balance-heavy, as they consistently offer the most diverse options in the wide segment (for that, we thank you, New Balance).

We’ll keep updating this list throughout the year (organized alphabetically, btw), so check back for new additions from time to time. Should you have any questions or shoe requests, leave a comment below or hit me up on the gram!

Altra Provision 4.0

altra provision 4 side

  • Weighs 10.7 oz. (303 g) for a US M10.5
  • 0 mm drop (27 in heel, 27 in toe)
  • Stability

Although Altra doesn’t make wide options, they are known for their foot-shaped toe box (Kurt Cobain wishes he used that for a song title) and more accommodating fit. That’s why I’ve been able to wear the Torin, Duo, and Escalante. The Provision 4 continues to be a viable option for people who need width, but it is on the snug side in the midfoot because the structural overlays wrap around both sides.

This may be weird to say, but the stand-out element of the Provision 4 is the textured insole. It’s extremely comfortable and cushioned. I could get down with more shoes having an insole like this. Even though the midsole felt firm, the insole does a great job offsetting it and overall, I enjoyed my miles. The guide rails and InnovArch support system provide excellent stability, although it’s already very stable thanks to the firm midsole and wide base.

The main issue I have with the Provision 4 is that the heel collar is very low and so my heel slips more than any other shoe on this list. Normally I’d just heel lock lace, but there isn’t an extra eyelet. Zero drop fans should be happy to have a good-looking solid stability option with the Provision 4.

Read The Review Shop The Shoe

ASICS GEL-Cumulus 22

  • Weighs 10.3 oz. (292 g) for a US M11 (I was sent a regular width half size larger which worked. Would have preferred the 10.5 2E)
  • 10 mm drop (31 in heel, 21 in toe)
  • Neutral

The Cumulus 22 might win the award for most-improved shoe, especially since its regular sizing still works for my 2E foot. ASICS took everything wrong with the 21 and fixed it. The 22 is almost an ounce lighter, has more flex grooves on the outsole, and uses a softer FlyteFoam midsole. The upper is great (as is the case with most ASICS) and while running, the toe-off was smooth as butter.

ASICS has a gem of a traditional daily trainer on their hands. No, it’s not the most exciting shoe, but it works great and is an excellent option for someone who doesn’t feel the need to have a multi-shoe rotation.

NOTE: Although the standard width worked for me, 2E and 4E options are available on ASICS’ website.

Read The Review Shop The Shoe

New Balance 860v10

new balance 860v10 side

  • Weighs 12.8 oz. (363 g) for a US M10.5 2E
  • 10 mm drop (31 in heel, 21 in toe)
  • Stability

New Balance put out a solid stability shoe with the 860v10. Yes, this is a heavy shoe. In fact, it’s the only shoe in the 12 oz. range on this list. However, it’s one of the smoothest stability shoes I’ve run in. You don’t get that slappy stiff ride. The combo of the entire outsole full of flex grooves and the firm TrueFuse midsole helps to roll you through your stride.

I don’t love the 3D molded ultra heel. It doesn’t cause any big issues with rubbing, but it isn’t the easiest to get on and I had some slight heel slip. Hello pull tab, you there?? These weren’t deal breakers in the slightest sense as the rest of the upper was on point.

Read The Review Shop The Shoe

New Balance 880v10

new balance 880v10 feature

  • Weighs 11.5 oz. (326 g) for a US M10.5 2E
  • 8 mm drop (30 in heel, 22 in toe)
  • Neutral

I keep going back to the New Balance 880v10 for long runs or easy miles. The Hypoknit upper is soft in all the right places and breathes well. Most importantly, I found the 2E width to be very accommodating within the midfoot.

Even though the shoe is on the heavier end of the spectrum (especially for a neutral shoe), the Fresh Foam X midsole provides a nicely cushioned ride that’s responsive enough to keep the legs feeling fresh (hence the name, duhhh).

This. Is. Your. Workhorse.

Read The Review Shop The Shoe

New Balance 890v8

  • Weighs 8.8 oz. (249 g) for a US M10.5 2E
  • 6 mm drop (25 in heel, 19 in toe)
  • Neutral

The 890 received quite an update in the newest iteration. The upper went from a knit to engineered mesh and the midsole graduated from REVlite on to the well-received FuelCell.

Even though the v8 gained 1.5 ounces, at 8.8 ounces it’s still on the lighter side and is the lightest wide shoe I’ve tried on this year.

The engineered mesh upper works well. I found it to be a smidge tight in the midfoot where the ‘N’ overlay is, but my foot felt much more secure taking turns compared to the Fresh Foam Tempo.

This has been the firmest FuelCell shoe I’ve run in. At slower paces, it’s not the most comfortable. It feels so much better and has better rebound when picking up the speed. The outsole grip turns well thanks to the ground contact REVlite foam and rubber.

The 890v8 reminds me of the FuelCell Rebel, but firmer and way more stable. I wouldn’t use it for recovery days or long slow miles. It’s a great wide option for tempo runs, faster pace long runs, and could be a solid choice for race day.

Review coming soon Shop The Shoe

New Balance Fresh Foam More V2

new balance fresh foam more v2 feature

  • Weighs 10.2 oz. (289 g) for a US M10.5 2E
  • 4 mm drop (34 in heel, 30 in toe)
  • Neutral

Here’s a shoe that felt super-cushioned while walking but turned out to be firmer and stiffer while running. It’s true what they say– if it walks like a More and quacks like a More, More is sometimes less.

The engineered mesh upper is both simple and efficient, while the midfoot and toe box is spacious in the 2E width. Somehow New Balance made this giant shoe over an ounce lighter than the 880v10.

I struggled with the FFM V2. The heel collar was a bust because the protruding padding irritated me. Also, the shoe feels firm and clunky. Not exactly what I envisioned for a max cushioned shoe.

In case you are still interested, although it is a neutral shoe, the wide base and firm midsole allow it to be more on the stable side.

Read the Review Shop The Shoe

New Balance Fresh Foam Tempo

new balance fresh foam tempo - stacked

  • Weighs 9.3 oz. (264 g) for a US M10.5 2E
  • 6 mm drop (24 in heel, 18 in toe)
  • Neutral

I’ll admit it, I wasn’t sold on the Fresh Foam Tempo after my first few runs. They felt too firm and harsh on my legs. Good thing I didn’t give up, because I’m enjoying them so much more now!

The FFT (yeah, I’m abbreviating) was the lightest wide shoe I’ve tried this year until the 890v8 arrived right before this roundup was posted. The Tempo isn’t as light as some other models from last year, but sub-10 oz. wide shoes are appreciated. Although the midfoot feels tight because of the stitching and ‘N’ overlay, it helps keep the foot in place. My biggest issue is actually that the toe box has too much room. Even though the shoe has great grip, it caused me to slow down a little when taking sharp turns. Lastly, the forefoot might be the most breathable of any shoe I own. During the cold morning or windy runs, my little toesies get quite chilly.

Fresh Foam X has felt so different in each New Balance shoe I’ve tried. Here, it provides a nice firm ride with a little bit of pop and just enough cushion to keep my legs from feeling dead. I love the low stack height as it gives a much better ground feel compared to the max stack shoes. The low stack also allows it to feel more stable compared to super bouncy neutral shoes.

The FFT is a great choice for the wide team as a fast trainer. I probably wouldn’t race or run any long distance or in them though, as the cushion is lacking. Oh, and at $110, it’s on the friendlier price side compared to the $150+ options out there.

Read The Review Shop The Shoe

New Balance FuelCell TC

side of the shoe

  • Weighs 9.9 oz. (281 g) for a US M10.5
  • 10 mm drop (30 in heel, 20 in toe)
  • Neutral

Wait, hold up. How am I listing a carbon plate shoe here? It doesn’t come in wide! Yes, this is true, but it works. The curve of the shoe makes it so the lateral part of my foot stays in the shoe and doesn’t muffin top over. My arches are what hang over on the medial side. However, the structure of the upper keeps my foot held in and my wide feet can fit! As of writing this, the farthest I’ve run in the FuelCell TC is 8 miles. I’ve had wide shoes (*cough* Nike) where I couldn’t even make it a mile…

Now that we’ve gotten that out of the way, let’s chat about New Balance FuelCell TC. This is hands down the most fun shoe I’ve ever run in. It’s also the only carbon plate shoe I’ve ever run in.

The upper is a lightweight mesh upper that I find to fit snug almost perfectly. The heel counter is lightly padded and I have no issue with the elf curl. The outsole has enough rubber in the forefoot to grip the road and the heel is mostly exposed FuelCell with some rubber.

The midsole is a massive stack of FuelCell with a carbon plate shoved in there which helps provide some stability. Although, runners who actually need stability may have trouble with the TC; it gets wobbly if you heel strike.

The bounce is real in the TC. It’s like a damn trampoline. Once I hit my stride, I’m propelled forward by the plate and up from the FuelCell. I can’t help but go fast in this shoe and it feels so easy!

Personally, I would (and will) race in the FuelCell TC. Why? Because it’s the only carbon plate shoe I’ve been able to run in. Yeah, they are heavy compared to other carbon racers out there, but most of the wide shoes weigh more than this so I’m used to it.

I’d like 12 more pairs of these in all different colors. Please, NB say that the RC is going to be the same fit because I’m losing my mind here that I’m somehow able to wear a standard width carbon shoe for my 2E feet. Until someone comes out with an actual wide carbon shoe, the FuelCell TC is a more than acceptable substitute.

Read The Review Shop The Shoe

HOKA ONE ONE Arahi 4

hoka one one arahi 4 - side

  • Weighs 10.8 oz. (306 g) for a US M10.5 2E
  • 5 mm drop (32 in heel, 27 in toe)
  • Stability

So far this year, HOKA has a hold on having one of the lightest wide stability shoes on the market. It does this even with having that patented HOKA stack height.

The Arahi 4 isn’t a big update from the previous model. The midsole and the outsole are the same. The upper was tweaked and is slightly more breathable.

The EVA J-Frame provides the weak ankle pronators with the stability needed and the early stage meta rocker gives a smooth toe-off. Don’t expect the super plush marshmallow that everyone talks about as this is on the firmer side for a HOKA, but still responsive, and can work well as a daily trainer.

In my opinion, the wide Arahi 4 runs a bit large. I could have easily gone with a size 10 instead of the 10.5 and I think this may have been partially why I was getting some blisters on my longer runs. Also, the midfoot was tight, so my very wide foot friends may struggle with this one.

Read the Review Shop The Shoe

HOKA ONE ONE Speedgoat 4

hoka one one speedgoat 4 side

  • Weighs 11.9 oz. (337 g) for a US M10.5 2E
  • 4 mm drop (32 in heel, 28 in toe)
  • Neutral

When trail shoes get talked about, the Speedgoat is usually in the conversation. It’s a shoe I was never able to wear because of the standard width, so I got pretty jazzed when I saw it was being made in wide. Spoiler alert: the width is great!

The EVA midsole cushion is amazing and I didn’t feel rocks or sticks while on the trails. This is normally a worry because I’ve gotten a super gnarly bruised heel before which kept me from running for a week. I will say the Speedgoat did feel a bit unstable because of the lack of ground feel.

If I were to buy another pair, I’d probably size down half a size. Between the super-thin tongue, weirdly obnoxious overlay right above the middle of the toe box, and struggle to get a good tight fit, I ended my runs with a few blisters. I think a lot of that probably came from my feet sliding forward at times.

The Vibram MegaGrip outsole provided some super solid traction while running down the trails, around switchbacks, and over wet rocks.

There aren’t too many trail options that come in wide. HOKA throwing the Speedgoat into the 2E ring is a game changer!

Read The Review Shop The Shoe

Skechers GOrun Ride 8 Hyper

  • Weighs 10.2 oz. (289 g) for a US M10.5 wide
  • 6 mm drop (30 in heel, 24 in toe)
  • Neutral

Although the GOrun Ride 8 Hyper came out late last year, Skechers is finally putting out a wide performance shoe with the famed Hyper Burst.

Hyper Burst is unlike any midsole I’ve run in. It’s cushioned, responsive, bouncy, and light. Everything I look for in a shoe. I was able to do some slow miles and use the Ride 8 as a recovery shoe as well as rip some fast paces.

Even though I tend to heel strike more when I get tired, the mid-foot strike zone assisted me with keeping a better stride longer. Goodyear rubber gives the confidence to take turns sharply and doesn’t require the outsole to be completely covered in it.

Heads up for the wide bois, I’m normally a size 10.5 (wide obviously). I returned them for the 10 and still had a ton of room. A 9.5 wide would have probably fit great. Hopefully Skechers fixes this sizing issue on future models.

Take everything you thought you knew about Skechers and throw it out. They are for real and bringing the fire. Thank you for finally giving us wide footers some of the Hyper Burst love!

Read The Review Shop The Shoe

 

14 Comments

  1. Thanks for the review! I’ve actually never bought wide-versions of shoes but leaned towards Altra and then TOPO – less boat-y all around – because it’s more forefoot width and height that I want. But TOPO has gone even shorter in its lengths and my size-13 just keeps slamming into the front.

    So do “wide” sizes actually open the toe box, is it more midfoot or heel? All three? What I really crave is a fun trail shoe (Altra Superior/TOPO MT-2) that has enough volume but without my foot flying forwards. I was thinking maybe a more natural last, but at a bigger width, might work…

    (Don’t worry about responding, this is all a pipe dream as my goldilocks shoe won’t exist, and I certainly didn’t manage to actually write a real question, lol)

    1. Ha. Eventually we will all find a shoe that is perfect! I can’t answer too well to the trail stuff since I don’t get trail shoes often (just cascadia and speedgoat in past year).

      As for wide shoes, yes, they should be wider (not just more upper material) in the forefoot and midfoot. I don’t think the heel really changes.

  2. YES! Thank you for bringing the love to us duck-feet yetis. More wide, and specifically more wide toe-box commentary on reviews would be much appreciated. In general, the other reviewers give it a passing comment but it doesn’t inform much for folks like us.

    1. You’re welcome! I’ll obviously comment on it for whatever wide shoes I get, but it’s tough for other reviewers in regular width shoes since they just don’t know.

  3. But hey, the NB fuelcell TC is available in 2e on the NB website. At least it was, when they still had stock.

  4. Hey Jarrett – Thank you for the review! I’ve really wanted to try the NB TC, but with my wide feet, wasn’t sure what size to go for: my usual size (hoping the toe box would be wide enough), or go up ½ a size to allow for my Yeti feet. How does the last in the Fuel Cell TC compare to other NB models? I wear a 12.5 2E in the 1080v10 and the Fuel Cell Rebel, but honestly, the Rebel is a little too short (I’ve lost the nail on my middle toe on both feet). Should I go up to a 13 in the TC? Any advice would be appreciated. Thanks!

    1. I haven’t worn the 1080v10. As for the rebel, I think it’s the same length. So if the rebel size was too short, the tc will probably be too.

      Worst comes to worst the size doesn’t fit and you return it.

  5. Thank you so much for making this list. As a wide footer, this is always a challenge. Can’t wait for the Gel Cumulus to be readily available!

    Hoping you also get a chance to try the new Nike Pegs – they have a “extra wide” option, and I’d love to hear if you’d give it your blessing.

    1. The cumulus 22 is available in 2E wide right now on running warehouse in the black and lime colorway. If you can’t find it, you can filter all the running shoes to wide and see everything like that. It makes it much easier to see every wide shoe available.

      I’m not sure I’ll get a chance to try the peg 37. It’s interesting that Nike has it in extra wide, but you can customize your own peg and then the wide option is a choice.

  6. This is awesome, thanks Jarrett! I measure borderline wide so it’s tough to find ones that fit as wide shoes tend not to work but regular doesn’t either. Just picked up the TC today and it feels amazing. Only question is it feels like it causes pronation a bit, like it’s not balanced and favors the outside of your foot. Did you get that sensation also?

    Also, the Endorphin Pro seems to be just wide enough to work too, though it definitely feels unstable at times.

    1. I’m not too sure about feeling like it causes pronation. But that’s just because I know when my form gets bad I pronate worse. So I try to focus on form while running in the TC.

      I’ve been wanting to try the endorphin pro since putting them on at TRE, but I think Thomas would notice if they went missing for a few days haha

  7. Hey,
    The best Wide foot Running Shoe is design to protect your feet from the road and to provide traction and also it has various specifications and technology as shoes vary with different brands. There are some advantages too when buying running shoes as it should have Superior Cushioning, Stability or Motion control, Supreme cushioning and energy return, Flexibility in the right places, Breathability, Traction on road or trails.

Leave a Response

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.