Last year I started training in more minimal shoes and shoes with lower heel to toe drop. I had run in Saucony Kinvaras, Saucony Fastwitch 4 and 5, New Balance MT 101, Pearl Izumi Streak II, Saucony Mirage, Saucony Shadow Genesis, Saucony Type A4, Saucony Hattori, Brooks ST-5 to name a few. After running a PR marathon in January, followed up by a great Ragnar in February, and a good showing at the HAT 50k in March, I was sold on minimal shoes. They are so much lighter, that at the end of long runs I still feel a spring in my step.
Then April came. During some striders at the end of a recovery run, my calves started to tighten severely. I didn’t listen to them and before I knew it… POW! My right calf locked up and wouldn’t release. It was excruciating. I thought someone had shot me in the calf with a rifle. I ended up going to a massage therapist for two months and scaling my runs down to slow minimal miles if any at all. Biking became my refuge.
The time off and the message seemed to get me back in a good place. My mileage was getting back to normal. I continued wearing the more minimal footwear. Things went well through the summer.
About a week and half ago I started to feel tight calves again. I got out the stick and the foam roller and things felt tight but all right. Then I went for a 20-mile training run in the Saucony Fastwitch 5. When I finished up my calves were screaming! A day later I did my recovery run and I felt the familiar tightening that happened before. I stopped running immediately this time. A thought occurred to me, last year when I was training for the GORE-TEX® TransRockies Run I trained in Brooks Ghosts. I stayed injury free that whole training cycle and I was putting in the miles. I decided I would go get a pair of Brooks Ghost 4s at lunch. When I tried running in the store I felt no stress on my calf. The very same calf that earlier that same day was ready to blow. Even though the Brooks have an elevated heel to toe ratio (about 12mm) I still manage to strike midfoot in them. So, I don’t think that a change in my stride occurs in the Brooks.
I ran in the Brooks that night and my calves felt fine. Did I find a magic bullet? Instantly my legs felt better. The only thing I can think of is that my calves needed a break. The slight difference in the heel drop gave them just enough support. I still did my Thursday track workout in the Saucony Type A4 (4mm drop) and was ok. I went back to using the Brooks for my long run. After 20 miles my legs felt fine. I have to admit at the end of my run those Ghost felt mighty heavy on my feet.
Now I am not giving up my minimal shoes, it just makes me think that maybe I need a mix in my shoe diet. While people are debating which is better and who is right in the great shoe battles that broke out after “Born to Run,” I am suggesting they can coexist. I also believe that running shoes are like glasses for vision. Not everyone needs them and those that do need them, need them in varying prescriptions. A person with 20/20 vision will tell you glasses are BS and only make your eyes worse. A person that can run well barefoot will tell you shoes are for dopes. If you need to wear glasses get a cool pair, if you need a traditional trainer run in them with pride. For me, minimal shoes are an “everything in moderation” kinda thing.
“Minimal shoes are absolutely going to work your calves more. The lower heel-forefoot drop means that the calves will stretch a bit more, and will be working at a little different point on their normal length-tension curve. Combine this with a midfoot-forefoot strike that triggers the stretch-shortening reflex on ground contact, and you see why a lot of people get calf soreness, at least initially, when switching into more minimal shoes. Furthermore, lower heeled shoes require greater eccentric work by the calves (contraction while the muscle is lenghtening), and eccentric muscle contraction is more likely to cause delayed onset muscle soreness.
I think you are right on in your approach – find the mix that works best for you. If mixing the Ghost in allows you to run pain free, I see absolutely no reason not to do it. You could also go for a lighter shoe with a traditional heel lift – maybe something like the Brooks T7 Racer or the NB MR1400. I don’t run all of my miles zero drop for the same reason – some days my calves need a break, and 4mm lift is about all I need to ease off a bit. Each individual is going to have a slightly different threshold determined by their anatomy, physiology, past, and present shoe wear. For example, if you spend all day in work shoes with a significant heel lift, ending the day with a run in minimal shoes may not be the best thing to do – your calf and Achilles adjust to the heel lift during the day, and taking it away abruptly can strain things. I now wear zero drop work shoes (Vivobarefoot Aqua) to avoid this issue. It may turn out that going minimal may require a more profound switch in footwear choices, as what you wear all day may be just as, if not more important than what you wear on an hour-long run.
As a tip – you can use a little foam heel wedge under the insole of a more minimal shoe to ease off the calf a bit – Newton is including one with the MV2. You could either cut your own out of a sheet of craft foam, or cut the heel off an old insole. Stick it under the insole of your minimal shoe and you can still reap the benefits of the lighter weight.”